Data on financial crime is not credible

13 December 2012

The government and police efforts to tackle financial crime - from business fraud to tax evasion - are hampered by a lack of accurate data about the nature and extent of offending, according to new research.

Most of the data available on financial crime is produced without a credible methodology, says Michael Levi, Professor of Criminology at Cardiff University, whose research was funded by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC).

"Typically, the information available on offending or threat is just a marketing hype," says Professor Levi. "It comes from business consultants who want to scare companies and government into buying services aimed at dealing with problems that may be a lot smaller than claimed."

"Even when public agencies do make a serious effort to produce data that they believe is carefully researched, it often lacks professional or public credibility," says Professor Levi. "In an age of cynicism, their efforts can be interpreted as an attempt to increase their budgets and powers. This is a crisis of authority and legitimacy."

Professor Levi has spent years researching the organisation and extent of financial crime and the ways in which police, regulators and private companies understand and respond to the various forms of threat.

A lack of clear thinking about how offenders and victims can and should be dealt with also makes it more difficult to tackle financial crimes in a coherent way, he believes. "We need a better informed, evidence-based debate about what kind of policing we want and should expect for financial crimes," he says.

"For example, large tax frauds are nearly always dealt with via a settlement payment. Yet social security fraudsters get a criminal record for crimes involving much smaller amounts of money. How do we justify treating offenders so differently?"

The research into tax fraud suggests there is a set of persistent offenders who are unlikely to be discouraged if their only punishment when caught is to pay a financial settlement anonymously. "They need to be prosecuted so they are taken out of circulation and to show others that this kind of behaviour will be dealt with seriously," he says.

Professor Levi has been sharing his research findings with UK and global organisations with a crime-fighting remit. They include the Financial Services Authority, the National Fraud Authority, the Association of Chief Police Officers and the European Commission.

"It is impossible to quantify the problem precisely, but the damage done by financial crime is real and the public are rightly worried about the risk of falling victim." he says. "Financial crime is one of the biggest business and social issues of our time. If we are to make a better job of dealing with the problem we need to move beyond oversimplified forms like 'organised crime' to work out how online and offline fraud and laundering are enabled and what it takes to change these opportunities and motivations."

For further information contact:

  • Michael Levi, Professor of Criminology, Cardiff University
    Email: levi@cardiff.ac.uk 
    Telephone: 029 2087 4376

ESRC Press Office:

Notes for editors

  1. This release is based on the findings from 'The Patterns, Organisation and Governance of Economic Crimes: Enhancing the Evidence Base', funded by the Economic and Social Research Council. The research was conducted by Professor Michael Levi of Cardiff University.
  2. Professor Levi used a variety of research methods to analyse the organisation of crimes and of public and private sector responses to them. These included reviewing policy documents, observing regulators and corporates and interviews with key stakeholders in Europe and globally.
  3. The Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) is the UK's largest organisation for funding research on economic and social issues. It supports independent high quality research which has an impact on business, the public sector and the third sector. The ESRC's total budget for 2012/13 is £205 million. At any one time the ESRC supports over 4,000 researchers and postgraduate students in academic institutions and independent research institutes.
  4. The ESRC confirms the quality of its funded research by evaluating research projects through a process of peers review. This research has been graded as very good.